Tyrese Haliburton showed his dominance on the court throughout the Indiana Pacers’ playoffs and NBA Finals series. Hali was more motivated to show his value, especially after a poll recognized him as the “most overrated” player in the league. But not everyone is still convinced.
Memphis Grizzlies star Kentavious Caldwell-Pope recently appeared on the Dawg Talk podcast with Jordan McGruder. He was asked directly whether he considers Haliburton a superstar.
“No. That’s what we’re going off of, and even I wouldn’t even build a team around Donovan Mitchell either,” he said.
KCP didn’t stop there. He drew a clear line between good players and those he considers true superstars while placing both Haliburton and Mitchell outside that elite group.
KCP says Tyrese Haliburton and Donovan Mitchell aren’t superstars 👀
— Swish Access (@SwishAccess) July 3, 2025
“We’re talking superstars — guys who elevate teammates and get wins when it matters. I can’t do that with Donovan Mitchell. And I’m 50/50 on Haliburton. He might put up 25 & 8, but he’s not consistent.”… pic.twitter.com/ctf8U5BiEI
“We’re talking superstars—guys who elevate teammates and get wins when it matters. I can’t do that with Donovan Mitchell. And I’m 50/50 on Haliburton. He might put up 25 & 8, but he’s not consistent,” KCP continued.
According to KCP, consistency is the true mark of a superstar. He acknowledged Haliburton’s clutch moments but expressed doubt over his full-game impact.
Click on ‘Follow Us’ and get notified of the most viral NBA stories via Google! Follow Us
“He’s clutch now, but like consistently throughout the game, I need you to be consistent with shooting the ball, your playmaking, all that. I don’t think he’s likeable. He’s getting there, but it’s still inconsistent.”
Pacers Rally Behind Haliburton As He Recovers from Finals Injury
Tyrese Haliburton is still in the process of recovering from the Achilles injury he sustained during Game 7 of the NBA Finals against the Oklahoma City Thunder. To show their support, the Indiana Pacers shared a heartfelt message on social media, encouraging fans to unite behind their star guard.
“Hearts for Hali. Calling all fans to help us let Tyrese know that Pacers Nation and the basketball world is behind him on his road to recovery,” the post read.
The setback was a crushing blow, especially after his stellar postseason performance and the Pacers’ inspiring run. Hence, rather than placing blame, fans are recognizing his leadership and dominance throughout the final series.
Also Read: Thunder vs. Pacers: Top 3 Historic Records Broken During The 2025 NBA Finals
