Football movies give us a lot of things. Some give us chills, others give us quotes. And then there are a few that leave us wondering how the characters even made the final script. This list takes a look at five of the best football movie characters ever written, and five of the worst ones to ever step on a fictional field.
Let’s break them down, one by one.
Who are the best and worst football movie characters?
Best: Rudy Ruettiger (Rudy)
Rudy is probably the most iconic underdog in football movie history. Played by Sean Astin, he didn’t have the size, strength, or natural ability to play for Notre Dame. What he did have was heart. Whether you think the story was a little overdramatized or not, the message still hits. The guy gave everything he had just for one shot. That single tackle he makes feels bigger than any game-winning touchdown. It’s tough not to root for Rudy.
Worst: Coach Bud Kilmer (Varsity Blues)
Coach Kilmer wasn’t just a bad coach. He was a walking billboard for everything wrong with high school sports. Voight’s portrayal of a win-at-all-costs coach made people want to throw their remotes at the screen. In the movie, he pushed injured kids to play, ran a toxic locker room, and was clearly stuck in some outdated football mindset. The worst part? He genuinely thought he was the hero. Watching him finally get exposed felt like a win for every player who ever had to deal with a coach like that.
Best: Bobby Boucher (The Waterboy)
Click on ‘Follow Us’ and get notified of the most viral NFL stories via Google! Follow Us
You can’t make a list like this without Bobby Boucher. What starts as a goofy Adam Sandler comedy ends up giving us one of the most memorable football movie characters of the ’90s. Bobby was awkward, misunderstood, and totally unstoppable when he got mad. From a waterboy to the MVP of the Bourbon Bowl, his transformation was hilarious and weirdly inspiring. You never quite knew what he was going to do next, but it always ended in a tackle.
Worst: Coach Red Beaulieu (The Waterboy)
Coach Red tried really hard to be the bad guy, but that’s kind of the problem. He wasn’t believable. He was just angry for no reason and mean for the sake of being mean. His entire personality was built around being jealous of Bobby and cheating his way to wins. There was no depth, no growth, and no real logic. Even for a comedy, Red came off more cartoonish than anything. And not in a good way.
Best: Rod Tidwell (Jerry Maguire)
Rod Tidwell had everything you want in a football movie character. Swagger, skill, and heart. Cuba Gooding Jr. didn’t just steal every scene he was in; he gave the film its energy. “Show me the money” wasn’t just a quote; it was a lifestyle. But Rod also had layers. He cared about his family, wanted respect, and had real struggles. When he finally got his big moment, it wasn’t just a win for him; it was a win for everyone who stuck by him.
Worst: Bob Sugar (Jerry Maguire)
Bob Sugar is what happens when you take every bad sports agent stereotype and roll them into one guy. He fired Jerry over lunch, stole all his clients, and smiled the whole time. He wasn’t interesting or even that threatening. He was just slimy. Nobody watches Jerry Maguire and says, “That Bob Sugar guy had a point.” He’s a one-note villain who exists just to make Jerry look better.
Best: Shane Falco (The Replacements)
Shane Falco might be the most underrated football movie quarterback of all time. Keanu Reeves gave him this calm, steady presence that made you believe he could lead any team. Falco was a has-been with nothing to lose, but when he got his second chance, he took full advantage of it. He led a team of misfits, outplayed pros, and gave us one of the most satisfying final drives in movie football history. Quiet, gritty, and believable.
Worst: Ray Finkle (Ace Ventura: Pet Detective)
Ray Finkle was supposed to be funny. But instead, he became one of the strangest and most uncomfortable parts of sports movie history. His backstory was bizarre, his behavior was extreme, and the twist ending hasn’t exactly aged well. From blaming a missed kick on Marino to plotting a kidnapping and identity swap, Finkle went from odd to just unwatchable. It was a lot, and none of it landed the way it was probably intended.
Best: Becky “Icebox” O’Shea (Little Giants)
Becky Icebox O’Shea didn’t just play football; she dominated it. She was the toughest kid on the field and never let anyone forget it. In a football movie full of silly humor and cheesy moments, Icebox brought the real intensity. She stood up for herself, led her team, and inspired a whole generation of kids, especially girls, who didn’t see themselves represented in sports movies. She earned her spot and then some.
Worst: Michael Oher (The Blind Side version)
Let’s be clear — this isn’t about the real Michael Oher. The real guy is a champion, on and off the field. But the version we saw in The Blind Side didn’t reflect that. The movie turned him into a side character in his own story. He barely had a personality and didn’t seem to understand the game he eventually went pro in. The story was supposed to be uplifting, but it came off like someone else took the credit. Even Oher himself said it hurt the way he was portrayed. That alone puts this version on the wrong side of this list.
