It’s over for Aaron Rodgers.
The New York Jets quarterback is catching major fire for his controversial retirement talks on The Pat McAfee Show.
Recently, former Jets general manager Mike Tannenbaum has stated that he believes Aaron Rodgers is effectively retired, commenting that “it’s over” for the quarterback.
Tannenbaum’s remarks came after the Jets informed Rodgers in February that they were moving forward without him. Despite expressing interest in finding a new team, Rodgers has not yet signed with any franchise.
Although he had discussions with the Vikings, Giants, and Steelers.
“Aaron Rodgers is an all-time great. It’s over, guys… Ironically, what [Steelers coach] Mike Tomlin would say [is], ‘We want volunteers not hostages.’ This is a guy that’s disinterested in being an NFL quarterback, which is fine. He’s earned that right. He’s made hundreds of millions of dollars. It’s over. We are drafting our next quarterback,’” the former GM said.
.@RealTannenbaum says it's "over" for Aaron Rodgers and that the Steelers should draft a QB 👀
— First Take (@FirstTake) April 18, 2025
"When a player is talking about being retired, they are." 😳 pic.twitter.com/sUymSPwMXx
Click on ‘Follow Us’ and get notified of the most viral NFL stories via Google! Follow Us
Tannenbaum majorly highlighted the importance of commitment in a quarterback. His remarks came in wake of Rodgers’ open thoughts on talking about retirement at McAfee’s show.
He quoted the late Coach Bill Parcells, who once said that when a player talks about retirement, he has already retired in his mind.
Rodgers faced a challenging stint with the Jets with a torn Achilles in his debut. Although he managed to bounce back in 2024 by playing all 17 games and throwing for 3,897 yards and 28 touchdowns.
However, the Jets had a disappointing season with a 5-12 record, leading to the decision to let him go. Following his release, Rodgers expressed that he doesn’t feel pressured to make a decision about his future, noting he is “going through a lot” in his personal life.
Rumors Link Aaron Rodgers To Saints As Potential Derek Carr Replacement
While the former Jets HC has openly blasted Aaron Rodgers, his days in the NFL are far from over.
Recently, rumors hint at the possibility of Rodgers joining the New Orleans Saints as a replacement for Derek Carr. Carr will undergo a shoulder injury procedure and could see Rodgers taking his place.
NFL RUMORS: The #Steelers are reportely losing PATIENCE with Aaron Rodgers.
— NFL Rumors (@nflrums) April 12, 2025
The #Saints could be a option now with Derek Carr INJURY pic.twitter.com/Ztw5Ivo2WA
With Carr’s future hanging in the balance, the Saints are weighing their options to find a quarterback, looking towards both the NFL Draft and free agency to fill the gap. ESPN’s Katherine Terrell recently mentioned Rodgers as a potential candidate.
However, bringing in a seasoned player like Rodgers isn’t as straightforward as it sounds, especially considering the financial implications and his long-term intentions.
While the idea of adding a player with Rodgers’ background is tempting, it does come with its own set of challenges. Terrell pointed out that if New Orleans were to sign him, they’d have to navigate both his salary demands and the financial commitment tied to Carr.
Also Read: Aaron Rodgers’ Greatest NFL Moments: A Look At Veteran QB’s Most Memorable Career Highlights
